In the Hall With the Knife: A Review

In the Hall With the Knife by Diana PeterfreundBlackbrook Academy, an elite boarding school hidden away in the woods of Maine, is no stranger to dangerous storms. With the latest one coming just before break, most students manage to make it home well before the the storm sets in. Which is why, when the headmaster turns up dead in the conservatory of one of the dorms, suspicion quickly shifts to the small group left behind:

Beth “Peacock” Picach isn’t interested in anything at Blackbrook unless it’s about tennis. Which is why Peacock is incensed when Headmaster Boddy wants to discuss her standing on the Blackbrook team just before the storm hits.

Orchid McKee came to Blackbrook to hide. Until information from the headmaster suggests that a dangerous piece of Orchid’s past life might have followed her to Blackbrook after all.

Vaughn Green is a townie and a scholarship student at Blackbrook. Vaughn balances a nearly impossible courseload and his less-than-ideal home life with working part-time as a janitor at the school giving him a front seat to Blackbrook’s iniquities. And its secrets.

Sam “Mustard” Maestor thought starting at a new school would give him a clean slate. What he didn’t count on was how different Blackbrook would be from his former school, an austere military academy. Starting in the middle of a historically bad storm and a murder investigation also doesn’t help.

Phineas “Finn” Plum is sitting on something big. Life-changing big. But one draconian school policy doesn’t mean he’s about to share it with anyone–especially not the headmaster.

Scarlet Mistry is used to being on top of the school’s gossip and the top liberal arts student thanks to her platonic power couple alliance with Finn. But even with all of her tricks, Scarlet doesn’t know what to make of a murder happening under her nose. Or the fact that her best friend is keeping secrets.

With one murder, zero trust, and a million motives, anyone could be the culprit in In the Hall With the Knife (2019) by Diana Peterfreund.

Find it on Bookshop.

In the Hall With the Knife is the first book in Peterfreund’s trilogy based on the board game Clue (find it on Amazon). The novel is broken up into alternating chapters between the six students. Scarlet is Indian American, Mustard is Latinx.

In her author’s note, Peterfreund mentions her love for the board game and the now classic movie it inspired. (Read more about the history of the 1985 film in Adam B. Vary’s Buzzfeed Article “The Crazy Story Of How “Clue” Went From Forgotten Flop To Cult Triumph.”) Peterfreund’s love for her source material is clear in this fitting reinterpretation of the classic game from the intrigue-filled backstory to the punny character names including janitor Rusty Nayler.

While quick to get to the inciting incident (Boddy’s murder, of course), the narrative can feel unwieldy while getting to know all of the characters–even with Peacock’s workout journal entries being obvious standouts. With plentiful motives and even more secrets, solving Boddy’s murder is just one of many mysteries surrounding Blackbrook promising more suspense–and murder–to come from this trilogy.

Unreliable narrators, red herrings, and clever dialogue from a really fun core cast make In the Hall With the Knife a winning mystery whether you’re a fan of the genre or the board game that inspired it.

Possible Pairings: S.T.A.G.S. by M. A. Bennett, Heist Society by Ally Carter, I Killed Zoe Spanos by Kit Frick, They Wish They Were Us by Jessica Goodman, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson, Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson, Killing November by Adriana Mather, The Cousins by Karen M. McManus, The Deceivers by Kristen Simmons, How We Fall Apart by Katie Zhao

May 2021 Reading Recap

Miss Print's Reading Recap

Planned to Read:

  1. Before She Ignites by Jodi Meadows
  2. Goddess in the Machine by Lora Beth Johnson
  3. Sherwood by Meagan Spooner
  4. A Spindle Splintered by Alix E. Harrow
  5. The Rules of Magic by Alice Hoffman


  1. Big Friendship: How We Keep Each Other Close by Aminatou Sow and Ann Friedman (audio)
  2. Coriolanus by William Shakespeare (audio)
  3. Roses and Rot by Kat Howard
  4. By the Book by Amanda Sellet (audio)
  5. Luck of the Titanic by Stacey Lee
  6. Measure for Measure by William Shakespeare (audio)
  7. Goddess in the Machine by Lora Beth Johnson
  8. Across the Green Grass Fields by Seanan McGuire (kindle)
  9. Alias Hook by Lisa Jensen (audio)
  10. By Night Vol. 3 by John Allison
  11. Sherwood by Meagan Spooner
  12. Before She Ignites by Jodi Meadows
  13. All Systems Red by Martha Wells (audio)
  14. The Ones We’re Meant to Find by Joan He
  15. Alanna: The First Adventure by Tamora Pierce (audio)
  16. Stretch by Scott Sonenshein (reread)
  17. Cumcumber Quest 3: The Melody Kingdom by Gigi D. G.
  18. Cucumber Quest 4: The Flower Kingdom by Gigi D. G.
  19. Timon of Athens by William Shakespeare (audio)
  20. Artificial Condition by Martha Wells (audio)


  1. Luck of the Titanic by Stacey Lee (preorder)
  2. The One We’re Meant to Find by Joan He (Owlcrate)

Recap Video:

You can also see what I read in April.